Hi there,
I got one thing wrong yesterday.
I said 1 in 8 of the people we hadn’t emailed in over a year had a dead address, compared with about 1 in 600 of our active users. And I said the only difference was time.
Here’s the full breakdown, and why time isn’t the whole story:
Still on our sending list, by last activity:
- Active in the last 90 days: 0.16% undeliverable (about 1 in 600)
- Last active 3 to 12 months ago: 0.62% (about 1 in 160)
- Last active over a year ago: 1.53% (about 1 in 65)
Not emailed in over a year:
- 12.4% undeliverable (about 1 in 8)
Look at that third line. Those people had been quiet for over a year too, but we kept emailing them, and only 1 in 65 had gone bad. The ones we’d stopped emailing were 8 times worse.
That’s because every send cleans your list a little. Bounces come back, your ESP suppresses them, and what’s left stays healthy. When you stop emailing a segment, the cleaning stops too. People keep changing jobs, abandoning inboxes and letting domains lapse, and you don’t find out until you send again.
So time matters, but what really hurts is time without sending.
On Black Friday, old segments come out of the drawer for the biggest send of the year. Most ESPs want bounces under 2%. Your quiet but still-mailed contacts use up most of that by themselves. The ones you stopped emailing come in at six times the limit.
What to do before Black Friday:
- Sort your list two ways: when people were last active, and when you last emailed them.
- Still emailing them and active in the last year: send as planned.
- Still emailing them but quiet for over a year: verify first.
- Haven’t emailed them in over a year, or ever: verify, then send one gentle “still want to hear from us?” email. Only the people who engage get the big promo.
We’re doing this ourselves. Every cold contact on our list gets verified before it’s invited to this series. The ones we haven’t emailed in years get a single permission email, not a sale.
Sean
CEO @ Emailable
Reformed list hoarder
P.S. Hit reply and tell me which ESP you use. I’ll send you the exact steps to build these two segments in it.
You’re getting this because you have an Emailable account. Not for you? The unsubscribe link below takes on click. Please use it instead of the spam button.
Update your email preferences or unsubscribe here
© 2026 Emailable, LLC
1395 Brickell Ave
Miami, FL 33131, United States