← All 12 emails
Day 04 of 12

We didn’t email 26,704 of our own contacts

They weren’t bad. Nobody could tell if they were real.

Hi there,

When we cleaned our own list for this push, 16.7% came back “risky.” Most of that was one thing: catch-all addresses.

A catch-all (or accept-all) domain says yes to every address, real or not. jane@ and asdf123@ get the same answer, so a standard check can’t tell them apart. You find out when you send. A dead one bounces in your real campaign, where it counts against you.

You’d think engagement would settle it. Not here. Catch-alls are mostly company domains, often with a security filter in front of the inbox. Many of those filters open emails and click links to scan them. So a catch-all can look engaged with nobody behind it.

What we did with ours:

  • Kept 4,355 with business domains where the person had used Emailable recently or bought from us.
  • Held back the other 26,704.

Notice what’s not on that list: opens and clicks.

Your rule of thumb: mail a catch-all only when a real person has shown up, through a reply, login, purchase or form fill. Opens and clicks alone don’t prove it. Keep the rest out of your biggest send of the year. If you want to try them, send them later in a small batch of their own, so any bounces stay out of your main campaign.

Ours was 31,059. What was yours?

Hit reply with the number of catch-alls from your last verification. A rough guess is fine. Not sure? Reply “not sure” and I’ll show you where to find it. (And yes, a reply is exactly the kind of proof I just told you to look for.)

Talk soon,
Sean, CEO at Emailable

P.S. Verify your list before your Black Friday send, not after it bounces. Through Dec 1, all credits are 20% off, and buying 1M+ adds 10% bonus credits on top.
https://emailable.com/lp/black-friday